“History, Heroes, and Hearty Meals: Exploring Peggy Schuyler’s Legacy and Sweet Lou’s in Schuylerville”

If you’re a history enthusiast or a fan of the play or movie Hamilton, you might find yourself with lingering questions about Peggy Schuyler, the youngest of the Schuyler sisters. On a recent trip, we ventured from Saratoga Springs, NY, to nearby Schuylerville in search of answers about Peggy and stumbled upon a culinary gem—Sweet Lou’s—led by Chef Louis Maggiore. Here’s what we discovered about both Peggy’s remarkable life and this hidden eatery.

The Legacy of Peggy Schuyler

Philip Schuyler, Peggy’s father, was a pivotal figure during the Revolutionary War. A major general in the Continental Army and a key political player, he and his family were deeply impacted by the British forces’ actions during the war. One of the most dramatic events occurred during the Saratoga campaign in 1777 when British General John Burgoyne’s troops burned down the Schuyler family’s home in Saratoga. This destruction forced the family to retreat to Albany for safety.

Years later, in 1781, Peggy’s bravery shone during a Loyalist and Mohawk attack on the Schuyler mansion. The raiders, searching for Philip Schuyler, demanded to know his whereabouts. Peggy’s quick thinking and composure under pressure likely saved her family that night. She cleverly misled the attackers by saying her father had gone to town. This act of courage has cemented her place as a heroine in Schuyler family lore.

Despite her strength in adversity, Peggy’s life was marked by health challenges. She passed away at the age of 42 in 1801. Peggy married Stephen Van Rensselaer III, a wealthy landowner and politician, in 1783. Their union brought together two of New York’s most influential families. Though she had three children, only one survived to adulthood.

For the true account of what transpired that night at the Schuyler Mansion, visit the Friends of Albany History page (Click to the right): The Mark of the Tomahawk – The Schuyler Mansion Raid, August 7, 1781.

Discovering Schuylerville

Schuylerville, formerly known as Saratoga, is steeped in history. The town was a critical site during the Revolutionary War and continues to honor its past.

While visiting, we couldn’t resist exploring the local culinary scene, which led us to Sweet Lou’s.

Sweet Lou’s: A Diamond in the Rough

Our visit to Sweet Lou’s began with a slight detour. We initially mistook the ground floor entrance for the restaurant but soon realized Sweet Lou’s is located upstairs. Chef Louis Maggiore himself met us on the stairs, setting the tone for the warm and inviting experience ahead. Inside, we were greeted by Kate, whose excellent service made us feel right at home. For those who prefer not to park on the street, there’s convenient parking behind the building.

Chef Lou’s philosophy is simple and heartwarming: “Food brings us all together, and what better way to make people happy than serving homemade food? All the items are named after people we have relationships with throughout our years together. Family, friends, and guests that come and visit Sweet Lou’s. We are not fancy, but do you really need to be fancy to serve great food?”

Sweet Lou’s is not a place for fine dining; instead, it offers a rustic, homey atmosphere where the food takes center stage. The Black and White Travel Chronicles staff gives it two enthusiastic thumbs up for its fresh, homemade dishes and warm hospitality.

The Menu: Comfort Food at Its Best

The menu at Sweet Lou’s is a testament to Chef Lou’s love for hearty, satisfying meals. One standout is the hand-cut fries, served à la carte with your choice of cheese sauce or gravy. These fries are a meal in themselves, made from large potatoes and cooked to perfection.

We also tried the “Loch Ness Monster,” a pulled pork sandwich whose name we suspect nods to the Loch Ness Monster—likely due to its enormous size. True to its namesake, the Loch Ness Monster was a beast of a sandwich, packed with tender, flavorful pork. Portions at Sweet Lou’s are generous, so come hungry or prepare to share. My wife and I split the Loch Ness Monster and still found it incredibly filling.

Beyond the food, it’s the people that make Sweet Lou’s special. Lou and Kate’s genuine warmth and care for their guests create an atmosphere that feels like dining with old friends.

Why Visit Schuylerville?

Schuylerville is a charming town that blends historical significance with modern appeal. History buffs will appreciate its Revolutionary War landmarks, including the Saratoga National Historical Park. For those interested in the Schuyler family’s legacy, a visit to this area offers valuable insights into their lives and the critical events of the era.

Meanwhile, Sweet Lou’s provides a perfect spot to refuel after exploring. Whether you’re visiting for the history or the food, Schuylerville is well worth the trip.

Schuylerville Awarded $4.5M Grant for Downtown Revitalization

In January, New York Governor Kathy Hochul, announced that Schuylerville will receive $4.5 million through the NY Forward program to revitalize its downtown. The funding, which is nearly three times the village’s annual general fund budget, aims to support a Strategic Investment Plan and launch key projects to transform the village ahead of the 250th anniversary of the Battles of Saratoga in 2027.

The village, with a population of about 1,400, appointed a seven-member NY Forward Task Force in 2022 to lead the grant application process. Saratoga County Chamber President Todd Shimkus recently met with local homeowners to discuss grant applications, which are due by August 2.

Schuylerville Mayor Dan Carpenter anticipates that most approved projects will begin construction in 2025, aligning with the community's vision to prepare for the significant 2027 anniversary celebration.

Final Thoughts

Our journey to Schuylerville to learn more about Peggy Schuyler’s life led us to a delightful discovery in Sweet Lou’s. Peggy’s story is one of courage, resilience, and familial devotion—qualities that continue to inspire. Likewise, Sweet Lou’s embodies a spirit of community and warmth that resonates with its patrons.

If you find yourself in the Saratoga Springs area, take the short drive to Schuylerville. Immerse yourself in history, savor some of the best comfort food around, and enjoy the hospitality of Sweet Lou’s. It’s a trip that satisfies both the mind and the palate.